I don't like the timing of the Stro deal or the return much. Stro was so annoying, but when I look at the Bauer 3 way deal and the rush signing of Grich over a player like Stro it causes me to pause. I don't know what Stro wanted but maybe it was a joke. In terms of head cases...Bauer is right up there with Stro if not worse.
Some of the rationalizations of the deal puzzle me. They seem convenient. "Well those arms aren't in the Top 100 now but they could be next month" etc. Would we apply that same standard if we were giving up a Top 100 guy? "Well he is Top 100 but you know...next month he might not be, so no big deal". "Hey Giles is hurt now...but it shouldn't affect any deal...cause you know....he might be fine in couple weeks". lol
I guess one question is was Fisher worth Cal A. too? Sanchez has sucked since 2016, but we aren't winning next year so was there potential to try to resurrect more value in pen or rotation? Impossible to know now...he has been awful and I HATED watching him.
Rationale for Fisher in part is he is LHH OF. Ok, so is Billy McKinney. Fisher is 26. The sample size is small but 35% MLB K rate. His AAA numbers this year are interesting but again...small sample. He gets on base. For a s***** Sanchez with possible return to some form and an milquetoast RHP middle reliever? Sure. But Anderson too? I don't know. Seems expensive for us.
The rest of the trades with Hudson etc are fine...they were found money and Joe Smith kind of deals.
I don't pretend to be an expert in evaluating these deals. With what knowledge I have, I calls em' as I see em'.