If you go back to the pre-season posts, I wanted Pillar traded because I thought Alford would put up similar numbers, and would cost less. I still stand by that, I feel given the playing time he'll D and Speed his way to a couple of WAR. I don't expect him to be an allstar, just a useful piece, and better than McKinney.
Fisher has LOOKED awful in the OF when I've watched him, he certainly fails the eye test. I don't think there's really enough of a sample size to judge his numbers on D, but I've seen some bad routes and some awkward plays beyond just the ball to the face bit.