Good points, not sure I entirely agree with your comments on his defense though. Negative in CF but he's not an albatross. His limited time in LF had him marked as a tremendous fielder, for what little that's worth. My guess is his defensive numbers would play up in a corner.
And yeah, I'm not in love with his bat either but he rebounded from that bad year. You say "huge pass" but what contract numbers are you hugely passing at? I'd be very interested in a 3 year deal.