I'm not trying to compare their career timelines, nor do I assume that every player starts at the same baseline and progresses equally each year.
Yes, Melky made it to MLB at age 20. That hardly puts him in the same category as the average 20 year old MLB hitter.
Surely, you're not going to set Melky's talent level in stone, based on his age of reaching MLB. Don't know if you've noticed but other than his steroid year, he's a pretty average player.
And again, I reiterate, the reason 24 year olds that haven't played MLB aren't that exciting, is because usually they've taken six years to get to AAA.
In Pillar's case, he's only been playing pro-ball for 2.5 years, so his ceiling has not been reached yet.
And you're right that Pillar has very little AAA experience, but there is a consistent pattern. He never has any difficulty with promotions, unlike the super-prospects that you guys drool over like Gose and Marisnick.