Well I think the fans and media need to readjust expectations for what justifies a spot in the hall.
I think we still use the arbitrary figures such as 500 homers, 3K strikeouts, 300 wins. But those kind of numbers, especially for pitchers, are just not attainable anymore.
Halladay feels like a hall of famer, and I believe he should get in. But knowing how stubborn voters are, I don't think he can get in.