Oh yes, let's use FIP for a single start. The 8 inning gem against Houston was one of the best pitched games on the team all season. He had 2 walks and 7 K's in a start against Boston if that's your thing. His first start this year may have been a bit better, but let's not pretend that he hasn't looked like a dominant SP for stretches. The only reason this narrative comes up is so people who were wrong can use the 'he's a different pitcher, no one could have seen this coming' line.