Thanks for the email. I probably would not have noticed this today without it.
I think everyone is making some good points.
We don't want to be punitive/draconian...
... but we do want to deter illegal adds
I think if it's noticed before any stats are accumulated then for rare infractions we should not punish at all. IIRC this is how we've done it in the past.
I don't remember any precedents of illegal adds where the player accumulated stats.
It makes sense to try to correct what happened to the current matchup - regardless of what the illegally added player actually did. So part of the punishment should be to sit one or more superior or equal players that week - if possible.
But it won't always be possible to do that, so we need a more consistent draft pick component. And the punishment needs to sting a bit if there is a windfall to the benching - say if Robbie Ray blows chunks, then jaysblue will have benefited from his punishment, which would suck farts.
Repeated issues should probably add some weight to the punishment.
FWIW it seems like jaysblue doesn't even check the spreadsheet sometimes. I can quickly find examples from our drafts:
http://www.bluejaysmessageboard.com/threads/25-A-Very-Darrelly-Dynasty-League?p=1174027&viewfull=1#post1174027
http://www.bluejaysmessageboard.com/threads/25-A-Very-Darrelly-Dynasty-League?p=519243&viewfull=1#post519243
He's essentially a repeat offender when it comes to lazy picks/adds.
And how egregious the add was should have some bearing. It's ridiculous to assume that, say, Senzel is unowned. It's more reasonable to assume that Tyler Beede is unowned at this point in his career.
And similarly, we need to consider whether the mistake was made in good-faith. If someone does what Silvergums alluded to and decides to stream an owned player because the punishment is worth it in context, then that owner will be treated severely and possibly removed from the league.
I'm assuming that jaysblue was just being kind of lazy, and not cheating.
I like the idea of the opponent picking who the offender specifically has to sit. If possible. I doubt thehurl will be here in time so I'll make an interim ruling in this case.
And I agree that we should record all this stuff for reference.
RULING --> Jaysblue should sit Robbie Ray this week and lose his 2019 4th round pick for this. The pick disappears.