My drastic CBA proposal would be something like:
- Kill the NL and AL. Pitchers don't hit anymore.
- Replace them with a Western League and Eastern League. This is geographic for travel purposes because we are also getting rid of divisions.
- Every team plays each team in their own League 5 times (145 games; probably a 3 game set and a 2 game set).
- Every team plays 8 teams from the other League 2 times (16 interleague games, 161 game schedule)
- Interleague opponents are based on some algorithm using last year's standings so each team gets a relatively fair distribution of opponent strength.
- The result of this is a pretty balanced schedule.
- Top 4 teams make the playoffs.
- Every series is 7 games long.
- Less off days during the 7 game series. Currently they get two off days for travel - make game 2 an afternoon game and they travel on that day. Only one off day during a 7 game series, after game 5, if it goes that far.
- Arbitration starts a year earlier, in a player's third year.
- Teams lose a year of control if a player makes their MLB debut after a certain age (it's getting nuts, some players are debuting at 27/28 and they will be cost-controlled for their entire careers. Doesn't seem fair).
- To penalize service time manipulation, some some of bonus in the final arbitration year for players who enter that year with excess service time. Example, if a player starts year "6" with 5.160 service time, that 160 extra days is used in some calculation to compensate the player and penalize the team.
- No more "competitive balance pick" ********. Revenue sharing is enough.
- All draft picks can be traded
- Just put J2 players in the draft. No need for a separate international draft. Bonus pools increase by the international spending budgets.
- Streamline the instant replay process. Managers should have to decide whether to challenge without the help of off-field staff. Review umpire support staff should be looking at close plays immediately in case they are challenged.
- Roy Halladay's hall of fame plaque gets a Jays logo