Nobody is having a start as rough or unlucky as Spanky.
Yadi, VMart, and Melky all have zero HR and OPS's under .641. These are all 100-150ish O-Rank players, who combined for 55 dingers last year. Walker has been shelled almost every time out. Holland and Cobb are both dead now. A few other bats are scuffling, to various degrees.
He's basically had one player take a step forward, and that's Archer.
His offense before the season looked old but adequate, almost all of them being top ~150 O-Rank players, and the top 5 in the rotation looked decent with Archer, Cobb, Walker, Holland, and Duffy. But it's ugly now.