If you're going to trade Bautista, you're probably rebuilding. Trading for a 30 year old pitcher doesn't really fit well there. Andrus, as discussed, doesn't have a tonne of surplus. Alfaro is intriguing but I think there are far better packages out there if we're really considering a Bautista trade. A 4.5 WAR true talent hitter (declining or not) with the control/contract he comes with is a very, very valuable asset.