I'm not a fan of Sanchez's long, dopey face, squirrel teeth and mouse ears. Bautista has the ear thing too and beady little eyes but his douchiness definitely raises his stock.
For me, Cecil's become a lot more handsome than when he first came up. The tats, weight loss and goggles really add to his appeal imo.
I am glad you threw Estrada in the handsome pile but don't really understand the appeal of Donaldson or Stroman.