It's hard not be biased by past success
Jays of course won the WS in 1992 after trading Kent for Cone and in 1993 after trading Karsay for Henderson as we all know
BUT I'll always wonder if they'd have won it either or both years without those trades
What would have happened if they'd had Kent around for 5 all star seasons and Karsay in the starting rotation?
Also do the Jays make the ALCS without David Price?
Smetimes it works and out and sometimes it doesn't
Do I want to trade Gurriel and a top 10 prospect for a legit frontline starter but no guarantee of even making the post season or advancing beyond the first round? Prob not
/end silly rant
It's impossible to know.