Good points
Defense will almost certainly be better next year. Reyes is only so so but we could be average or above average at every other position if Arencibia is gone for a plus defensive catcher.
Edwin, Bautista - average
Lawrie, Goins (?), Rasmus, Gose - above average
I guess Melky is a wild card and could be sub par if he plays every day
And, now that I look at that list, there are probably only 2 ELITE defenders there, and one of them (Gose) probably won't play every day.