The Top 50 Blue Jays of All Time: 5 to 3

[Mike LeSage]

Jays Centre is counting down the top 50 Blue Jays in franchise history. Check out prior entries in the series here:

• Introduction
• 50 to 46
• 45 to 41
• 40 to 36
• 35 to 31
• 30 to 26
• 25 to 21
• 20 to 16
• 15 to 11
• 10 to 6

As you might expect for the top of this list, we’re talking about guys that had an extended Blue Jays career, each with over a decade in Toronto. With their time spent here (4000+ combined games) and the impact they each had on this franchise, it may be surprising to think that each of them also has a signature game, one the majority of fans think of first when hearing their name. 

No. 5: José Bautista

• 2008-2017
• 6x All-Star, 3x Silver Slugger
• Franchise All-Time #1: position player bWAR (38.4), position player fWAR (36.2)
• Single Season #1: position player bWAR (8.3), offensive bWAR (8.4), home runs (54), walks (132), AB per HR (10.5), win probability added (8.0), wRC+ (180), isolated power (.357)

The Career: Bautista was famously acquired by the Blue Jays for the always popular “player to be named later,” and it would only be with the power of hindsight that we came to recognize this as perhaps the most valuable trade in Toronto history. In 2010, he set the franchise record for home runs in a single season and led the league with 54. He would lead the league again the following year with 43 home runs, and his 132 walks in 2011 (including 24 intentional ones) would also be league leaders, making the continued power all the more impressive. From 2010 to 2015, no one would hit more homers than Bautista’s 227, and he was rewarded with an All-Star appearance each of those seasons. Bautista was easily one of the most feared batters of his time.

The Game: There might not be a more iconic moment in the top five than the bat flip game. In 2015, the Blue Jays were playing in the playoffs for the first time since winning the World Series in ‘93 – it was a long drought. The seventh inning of Game 5 of the ALDS had about 10 wild moments before Bautista even came to the plate, but once he did and sent the ball 431 feet to left center – and his bat 40 feet straight up – he cemented himself into Toronto sports history.

No. 4: Tony Fernández

• 1983-1990, 1993, 1998-1999, 2001
• 4x All-Star, 4x Gold Glover
• Franchise All-Time #1: Games played (1450), defensive bWAR (12.3), hits (1583), singles (1160), triples (72) 
• Single Season #1: Games played (163), at-bats (687), singles (161), triples (17)

The Career: Tony Fernández, the player so nice they acquired him twice, three times, four times! Signed as an amateur free agent, reacquired by trade and then signed as a free agent twice. Fernández spent 12 of his 17 major league seasons in Toronto and has played more games for the Blue Jays (1450) than any other player to wear the Toronto uniform. His four Gold Gloves came in consecutive seasons from ‘86 to '89. He missed out on the award in 1990 and was subsequently (possibly unrelatedly) traded in the offseason, along with Fred McGriff, in the biggest trade the franchise has seen. During the ‘93 season, the defending champion Jays would reach an agreement with the Mets to reacquire Fernández. His postseason performance was a major reason for the second championship. He would leave and return twice more as a free agent, most impressively representing Toronto at the 1999 All-Star game at age 37. 

The Game: Perhaps he was fueled by missing out on the ‘92 series, or perhaps he was just born to hit the ball and so that’s what he did. In Game 4 of the ‘93 World Series, Fernández put together three hits and knocked in five runs to help lead Toronto to victory, earning almost 30% of the win probability generated in the game. A pair of singles into shallow right field, a hard hit grounder into left and a chopper with the bases loaded that Fernández came within a quarter-of-a-step from beating out combined for five RBI and propelled Fernández to his first (and only) World Series trophy.

No. 3: Carlos Delgado

• 1993-2004
• 2x All-Star, 3x Silver Slugger
• Franchise All-Time #1: Offensive bWAR (39.4), slugging percentage (.556), OPS (.949), plate appearances (6018), runs (889), total bases (2786), doubles (343), home runs (336), RBI (1059), walks (827), extra base hits (690), HBP (122), intentional walks (128), AB per HR (14.9), win probability added (28.9)
• Single Season #1: Slugging % (.664), OPS (1.134), total bases (378), doubles (57), RBI (145), wOBA (.471), runs created (186), extra base hits (99), times on base (334)

The Career: Delgado made his debut with three games remaining in the 1993 season. He came into the game in the bottom of the sixth inning as a replacement for catcher Randy Knorr and drew a walk in his only AB, marking his first time on base. He would go on to reach base 2361 more times, a mark that no other Jay can match. The fact that he came up as a catcher and made that one appearance also makes him a sneaky Immaculate Grid pull. Delgado’s timing in Toronto seems almost cruel. In the system, but not on the team when they won the back-to-backs and then gone a decade before the Jays would see the playoffs again. Delgado never got a playoff moment like Bautista or Joe Carter, but that didn’t stop him from putting in work every regular season. Only one player in franchise history has played more games than Delgado, and that's Fernández. Delgado finished second in MVP voting in 2003 while leading the league in RBI and OPS. Once he established a full-time role, he averaged 36 home runs per season for nine years. The best homegrown power source the Jays have ever had.

The Game: Towards the end of that 2003 season, Delgado put on one of the most impressive hitting displays ever seen in Toronto. In the bottom of the first inning, he hit a three-run homer to right field. In the fourth inning, it was a leadoff solo shot. The sixth inning? Another leadoff solo shot marked the fifth time in Delgado’s Blue Jays career that he had a three-homer game. Then, in the eighth inning, Delgado made history. Absolutely crushing a ball for his fourth home run of the day, becoming the first (and still only) Blue Jay to have a four-home run game.

View full article

[Seth Stohs]

Tony Fernandez was so underrated during his playing days. I think teams understand how good and how important his defense was, but he was unique for an '80s shortstop in that he could hit a bit too. 

[mellowgold2]

I know why, obviously, but any top Blue Jays of all-time without Alomar will always look weird to me