Question Time

[Frag]

Yes, I'm taking this from Bluebird Banter, but I thought it was a fun exercise. As well, I know that the offseason isn't over and more transactions will be done. Anyway, it goes as follows:

 

If you could take one player off each team within each division and put him on the Jays, who would you pick? For example, of the 5 teams in the AL Central, which 5 players from each team would you want to roster on the Jays. Future value would be something to consider. Take into consideration the players already on the Jays roster.

 

Bonus question: If you had a choice of taking one player off of each NL Central team or 5 players off of the Chicago Cubs, which would you choose?

[BTS]

Does salary matter?

[Frag]

Does salary matter?

 

It didn't seem to matter much according to BBB, so no.

 

Also, if necessary, prospects can be included.

[BTS]

Cubs

Rizzo

Bryant

Arrieta

Heyward

Lester

 

NLC

Bryant

Carpenter

McCutchen

Votto

ugh... Lucroy?

 

You could make the argument that the Cubs are better:

 

Bryant = Bryant

Rizzo > Votto when factoring in age

Heyward > Carpenter, especially given age

Lester > Lucroy (I guess, you could argue either way)

Arrieta < McCutchen

[GD]

Cardinals: Adam Wainwright

Cubs: Kris Bryant

Pirates: Andrew McCutchen

Brewers: Ryan Braun

Reds: Joey Votto

 

Then you trade one of Bau/EE

[GD]

Cubs

Rizzo

Bryant

Arrieta

Heyward

Lester

 

NLC

Bryant

Carpenter

McCutchen

Votto

ugh... Lucroy?

 

You could make the argument that the Cubs are better:

 

Bryant = Bryant

Rizzo > Votto when factoring in age

Heyward > Carpenter, especially given age

Lester > Lucroy (I guess, you could argue either way)

Arrieta < McCutchen

 

Russell > Heyward as an asset if you consider contract iimo

 

If you don't then Heyward

[Maahfaace]

Yes, I'm taking this from Bluebird Banter, but I thought it was a fun exercise. As well, I know that the offseason isn't over and more transactions will be done. Anyway, it goes as follows:

 

If you could take one player off each team within each division and put him on the Jays, who would you pick? For example, of the 5 teams in the AL Central, which 5 players from each team would you want to roster on the Jays. Future value would be something to consider. Take into consideration the players already on the Jays roster.

 

Bonus question: If you had a choice of taking one player off of each NL Central team or 5 players off of the Chicago Cubs, which would you choose?

 

Considering the current threads on this board Im surprised the question wasn't "If you had a choice of banging one player off of each NL Central team or 5 players off of the Chicago Cubs, which would you bang?"

[GD]

Considering the current threads on this board Im surprised the question wasn't "If you had a choice of banging one player off of each NL Central team or 5 players off of the Chicago Cubs, which would you bang?"

 

Cubs: Rizzo

Cardinals: Wainwright

Pirates: Harrison?

Brewers: Braun

Reds: Votto

[Laika]

Schwarber

Schwarber

Schwarber

Schwarber

The Schwarber

[Boxcar]

Heyward

McCutchen

Votto

Wainwright...I guess. If Lynn wasn't injured, I'd take him here instead.

Braun or Lucroy

 

I actually think I'd take 5 Cubs.

[Boxcar]

Russell > Heyward as an asset if you consider contract iimo

 

If you don't then Heyward

 

Teach us the ways, oh great one.

[Frag]

I see everyone is interested in the bonus question. lol

[Boxcar]

Cubs: Rizzo

Cardinals: Wainwright

Pirates: Harrison?

Brewers: Braun

Reds: Votto

 

Lol wut

 

Kris Bryant plays for the Cubs

 

Cards - Matt Carpenter

Cubs - Kris Bryant

Pirates - Gerrit Cole

Reds - Jesse Winker

Brewers - Jonathan Lucroy

[King]

Lol wut

 

Kris Bryant plays for the Cubs

 

Cards - Matt Carpenter

Cubs - Kris Bryant

Pirates - Gerrit Cole

Reds - Jesse Winker

Brewers - Jonathan Lucroy

 

Mods

[Maahfaace]

Lol wut

 

Kris Bryant plays for the Cubs

 

Cards - Matt Carpenter

Cubs - Kris Bryant

Pirates - Gerrit Cole

Reds - Jesse Winker

Brewers - Jonathan Lucroy

 

Mods

 

I think its his "bang" list King

[GD]

Lol wut

 

Kris Bryant plays for the Cubs

 

Cards - Matt Carpenter

Cubs - Kris Bryant

Pirates - Gerrit Cole

Reds - Jesse Winker

Brewers - Jonathan Lucroy

 

just did it off the top of my head tbh

 

but Rizzo has that macho Harvey Specter allure

[Abomination]

Cubs

Bryant

Rizzo

Arrieta

Heyward

Schwarber / Russell

 

NLC

Carpenter

McCutchen

Bryant

Arcia ?

Votto

 

I think I'd take the 5 cubs.

[King]

I think its his "bang" list King

 

http://www.milb.com/images/608385/t423/180x270/608385.jpg

[Boxcar]

http://www.milb.com/images/608385/t423/180x270/608385.jpg

 

What a beautiful man

[Maahfaace]

http://www.milb.com/images/608385/t423/180x270/608385.jpg

 

i dunno, boxy got some wierd man love taste

[Maahfaace]

What a beautiful man

 

hahaha

[TheHurl]

AL West

 

Angels - Trout

A's - Gray

Astros - Correa

M's - King Felix

Rangers - Hamels

[GD]

AL West

 

Angels - Trout

A's - Gray

Astros - Correa

M's - King Felix

Rangers - Hamels

 

I don't think any of this is even debatable tbh

[Captain Adama]

I don't think any of this is even debatable tbh

 

Maybe Odor instead of Hamels? Only one I can see that is even defensible.

[Frag]

NL East:

 

Mets: Noah Syndergaard (could choose any of their top 3 pitchers)

Nationals: Bryce Harper

Braves: Freddie Freeman

Marlins: Giancarlo Stanton

Phillies: Aaron Nola?

 

A rotation consisting of Syndergaard, Stroman, Nola, Happ, and Dickey/Estrada would be good. Freeman would replace the Smoakabello platoon. Harper is obvious. If one of EE/Bautista is traded, then Stanton fits on this team. If not, then picking Jose Fernandez is understandable.

[Laika]

I don't think any of this is even debatable tbh

 

Yu.

[Laika]

Maybe Odor instead of Hamels? Only one I can see that is even defensible.

 

I'll take one Nomar Mazara, thx

[Frag]

AL West

 

Angels - Trout

A's - Gray

Astros - Correa

M's - King Felix

Rangers - Hamels

 

Replace Hamels with Yu Darvish, and I completely agree.

[Laika]

NL East:

 

Mets: Noah Syndergaard (could choose any of their top 3 pitchers)

Nationals: Bryce Harper

Braves: Freddie Freeman

Marlins: Giancarlo Stanton

Phillies: Aaron Nola?

 

A rotation consisting of Syndergaard, Stroman, Nola, Happ, and Dickey/Estrada would be good. Freeman would replace the Smoakabello platoon. Harper is obvious. If one of EE/Bautista is traded, then Stanton fits on this team. If not, then picking Jose Fernandez is understandable.

 

You'd want JP Crawford

 

I'd probably take deGrom over Thor too but it's close enough

[Frag]

You'd want JP Crawford

 

Would require moving Tulo off SS (or trading him).