A Very Darrelly Dynasty League

[BTS]

Seager confusion?

[Cyborg]

Seager confusion?

 

Theyre similar in value though.

[BTS]

Theyre similar in value though.

 

Yeah, but KingKat is in a position where little Seager is more attractive.

[BTS]

jays_fever's window expires at 11:07 AM, with Gibbers on deck.

[Dr. Dinger]

Theyre similar in value though.

 

Disagree.

[GeorgiaPeach]

I select SP-Jarred Cosart-MIA

[GeorgiaPeach]

Lyon Tamer emailed he's on the clock.

[Sammy225]

f*** what a steaming pile left lol.... I am going to take a chance on Jared Weaver LAA SP.... Doing something semi-useful

[BTS]

Wow, the remaining SP are trash. I took Trevor Cahill. Hoping for some sweet SP holds.

[Sammy225]

Wow, the remaining SP are trash. I took Trevor Cahill. Hoping for some sweet SP holds.

 

Your telling me i went through the pitching list a threw up a little bit.

[z3r0s]

Randal Delgado.

[z3r0s]

Gryff back up, whats the procedure given his last pick is expired? 6 hours or immediate skip?

[BTS]

Gryff back up, whats the procedure given his last pick is expired? 6 hours or immediate skip?

 

Another 6 hours.

[z3r0s]

I emailed him

[BTS]

I emailed him

 

He's been on the forum for like half an hour. Not sure why he hasn't picked.

[jaysblue]

Wow, the remaining SP are trash. I took Trevor Cahill. Hoping for some sweet SP holds.

 

Nice pick. I was thinking of grabbing him, though the back end of the Cubs BP is pretty crowded. Still, he had a nice stint with the Cubs which is encouraging!

[Cyborg]

Disagree.

 

Kyle is a monster. Highly doubt Corey will be a better hitter than him.

[Boxcar]

Kyle is a monster. Highly doubt Corey will be a better hitter than him.

 

BP ranked him as the top prospect with a 70 hit tool, though

[KingKat]

BP ranked him as the top prospect with a 70 hit tool, though

 

Was it BP who said that Kyle was his floor? Someone said that anyways and it seems pretty egregious as a floor for any prospect but it does give an ideal of just how highly he's thought of.

[Dr. Dinger]

Kyle is a monster. Highly doubt Corey will be a better hitter than him.

 

Sorry, a career 115 wRC+ does not qualify him as a monster in any way, shape, or form. He is consistently useful and above average, but Corey has a much higher ceiling.

[Dr. Dinger]

BP ranked him as the top prospect with a 70 hit tool, though

 

Every prospect site ranked him as the top prospect, if I'm not mistaken.

[Cyborg]

Sorry, a career 115 wRC+ does not qualify him as a monster in any way, shape, or form. He is consistently useful and above average, but Corey has a much higher ceiling.

 

Safeco supresses him more than the park factors say because of his flyball profile. Id say hes a 130 guy in a different park.

[Dr. Dinger]

Safeco supresses him more than the park factors say. Id say hes a 130 guy in a different park.

 

Huh? Isn't that baked in? wRC+ is park adjusted, that's why I didn't start with wOBA (which is again mediocre). And Safeco is part of the package with Kyle, he's signed long-term.

[Cyborg]

Huh? Isn't that baked in? wRC+ is park adjusted, that's why I didn't start with wOBA (which is again mediocre). And Safeco is part of the package with Kyle, he's signed long-term.

 

Due to his flyball profile. 124 career wRC+ on the road.

 

I said better hitter not fantasy numbers.

[Cyborg]

Smoak is the prime examole. Didnt change much year to year but went from 79 wRC+ to 107 wRC+ Safeco to Rogers Centre. Park factors dont always apply to everyone, hitters that have more extreme profiles in more extreme parks can be grossly under or overvalued.

[Dr. Dinger]

I said better hitter not fantasy numbers.

 

Neither. Corey will be a true monster.

[Dr. Dinger]

Smoak is the prime examole. Didnt change much year to year but went from 79 wRC+ to 107 wRC+ Safeco to Rogers Centre. Park factors dont always apply to everyone, hitters that have more extreme profiles in more extreme parks can be grossly under or overvalued.

 

Smoak is a terrible example. Those were just the low and high ends of his normal career variance and they also come with platoon sample sizes. He's a career 96 wRC+, right in the middle of those two bookends.

[tafkasg]

How long you wager until he moves off short?

 

I traded him based on that presumably happening, watching this unfold has been upsetting.

[Boxcar]

Smoak is a terrible example. Those were just the low and high ends of his normal career variance and they also come with platoon sample sizes. He's a career 96 wRC+, right in the middle of those two bookends.

 

I really don't understand how what Cyborg is saying doesn't seem plausible to you. Is it because you've gone full Gibbers and refuse to believe a young stud might not be a hall of fame level superstar?

[Dr. Dinger]

How long you wager until he moves off short?

 

I traded him based on happening, watching this unfold has been upsetting.

 

He'll have at least 2 full years there, IMO. After that is anyone's guess, but I think he'll hold SS eligibility for a year or two even after transitioning. Even at 3B, he's a stud. Strong chance to put up multiple .900+ OPS seasons in his career (probably not before age 25 tho). Just a very special bat.