You're completely right! I'm not saying you shouldn't trade value or pay up for good players. But those players have to be ACTUAL superstars. To me personally, a defensive specialist with around a league average bat is NOT a guy you want to push all your chips in on. To you, he was! That's completely fair. We'll see in the next 3 years who was right, but I disagree with the move.
Personally, I would love to trade Tiedmann this winter for an actual superstar. Just not for Varsho.