I don't think it is mission critical to resign either of Semien or Ray. The Jays should NOT overpay for either of these guys. But I am more partial to Semien, as long as he is OK continuing to play 2B (or is he a possible 3B candidate?). Semien is the real deal, but I fear Robbie Ray has peaked and now that the AL has had a full season to see him, he is very vulnerable because he has succeeded in 2021 by mainly using the 4SFB and SL. Two pitch starting pitchers often end up like Ray did this past Thursday (lit up 3rd time through the order by the Yankees). I would keep him at 2 years $30M, with a 3rd year option at $20 M or $5M buyout ($35M guaranteed). I would consider Semien at 4 years, $90-100M, to be worth signing.