The conversation isn't whether Soto is good or not, it's whether adding him while not being able to upgrade the team on multiple other fronts is good enough. We had Jose/Edwin for years and couldn't win crap until we put a complete full team around them with Donaldson, Martin, Tulo, bullpen etc.
Don't get me wrong though, I'd be one of the first to get a Soto jersey... This team just has far too many years holes, which we know isn't going to get patched up with our farm system.