I saw the same set of quotes. I do largely agree that this is likely a case of where it's prudent to avoid trying to fix something that isn't broken. Kirk has been flat out mashing over the last 2+ months of the season with the present approach as evidenced by a 142 wRC+ over his last 222 PA. The results are lagging behind the expected statistics to a large degree to be certain, so perhaps over time Popkins and the rest of the hitting staff can make a few tweaks to unlock a tad more over the fence power in time.
With his best in MLB defense behind the plate he's amassed a team best 2.8 FWAR over this span which is a remarkable outcome. I was always hopeful that he could rediscover the form at the plate that he displayed during the career best 2022 season and combined with the tremendous improvements behind the plate in recent seasons we are enjoying peak Kirk right now. Thank goodness the front office got the extension done in spring training as it would costed a lot more money to do this now given the offensive resurgence.
Laureano is an interesting trade candidate, but surprisingly he's running a sizeable reverse platoon split this season as evidenced by only 94 wRC+ vs LHP and 163 wRC+ vs RHP. This is more of a small sample size anomaly compared to the rest of his career as evidenced by a career 120 wRC+/107 wRC+ LHP/RHP split. He certainly fits the bill as a right handed outfield bat for the club and is almost certainly an upgrade on Davis Schneider, so I'll place a tentative thumbs up towards acquiring him based on potential acquisition cost. I looked up his advanced defensive metrics and he doesn't appear to be a realistic option to spend any time in center field but is likely passable in the corners.
I had a look at Reynold's and there are aspects of his game to like. He's swinging the bat from both sides of the plate with the highest average speeds and fast swing rates since Statcast started tracking bat swing speed. The quality of contact metrics are all at career best rates as well which is also very encouraging. It appears as though he's been remarkably unlucky with batted ball results as the .360 xwOBA is very solid, but the results are poor at .295 wOBA. Perhaps this is something that could even out over time. One concern I have is that he appears to have lost all of his defensive ability to the point where he's a massive liability in the field. With the team already employing below average defenders in Springer and Santander acquiring Reynolds would likely force two of these guys into the corners in most games and that would weakness the outfield defense tremendously.