Lets compare notable names to a team like the Red Sox:
Jays
2014
Hoffman (used to acquire Tulo)
2013
Boyd
Graveman
2012
Stroman
Alford
2011
Pillar
Norris
DeSclafani
Nola (unsigned)
Beede (unsigned)
2010
Syndergaard
Sanchez
Pompey
Dyson
Nicolino
Woj
Bryant (unsigned)
2009
Hutchison
Marisnick
Gomes
Loup
Goins
Tepera
Paxton (unsigned)
2008
Cooper
Pastornicky
Thames
Farquhar
2007
Cecil
Scrabble
JPA
Mastro
2006
Snider
Jon Diaz
2006-2008 was awful. 2009-2012 were excellent and from then on is still TBD.
Red Sox
2014
?
2013
?
2012
Brian Johnson
Carson Fulmer (unsigned)
Alex Bregman (unsigned)
2011
Betts
Swihart
Bradley Jr.
Shaw
Owens
Barnes
2010
Ranaudo
Coyle
Cechinni
Renfroe (unsigned)
2009
?
2008
Christian Vazquez
Casey Kelly
Lavarnway
DeSclafani (unsigned)
Shaw (unsigned)
Alex Meyer (unsigned)
Yan Gomes (unsigned)
2007
Grandal
Strickland
Middlebrooks
2006
Belt
Masterson
Bard
Kalish
Awesome 2011. 2008-2010 are duds. 2012-2014 look likes duds at the moment but could change. They also hit with Belt and Grandal in 2006 and 2007 but didn't enjoy either success.
I'd say the Blue Jays drafts under AA were better in terms of volume and overall success. We drafted better pitching, Red Sox better batting.
Betts
Grandal
Belt
Swihart
Bradley
Masterson
Shaw
Vazquez
+relievers
vs.
Syndergaard
Stroman
Pillar
Gomes
Sanchez
DeSclafani
Norris
Hutch
Alford
Pompey
Marisnick
Goins
Boyd
Graveman
+ relievers