That's a tough one for me. I love both guys. The thing is that Sanchez's complete lack of command is maddening and suggests that he shouldn't even be pitching above AA ball except that he somehow finds it in the bullpen and it transforms him into a valuable backend bullpen guy.
However, I'm not educated much in the submetric stats thing so you'll have to forgive my admitted ignorance.
With that said, I think Sanchez has superior stuff and with the same command, I'd take Sanchez ten times out of ten. Aaron has good enough stuff that with two strikes, he continued to throw that har sinker and guys weren't hitting it even when they knew it was coming. I know it's completely ignorant to say, "well, if you'd just take away his walks." Aaron still has a lot of time to learn his release point. It takes some guys longer than others. I'm extremely hopeful that he will learn it and when he does? Jeez, if we could sign Price long term? And with how much Stroman was trying to help Sanchez and with them being good friends?
1. Price
2. Stroman
3. Osuna
4, Sanchez
5. Anyone, anyone, Bueller
That rotation has the potential to be explosive, even with Hutch as our number 5 still