Its not whether or not this move works out. Thats irrelevant. Its the nature of the move made that bothers me. Yesterday was the game you use Redmond. Today 4 down with our lineup, you do whatever it takes to not give up another run. That means using your middle relievers.
This is a bad bad move and exposes the fact that at the end of the day, John Gibbons does not think ahead. Those things are beyond him. Like AA he is playing it by the day.