Why do you seem to think WAR is equal to a hockey player's +/-? If Aaron Loup blows 5 games, you could argue he's directly responsible for 5 losses to the Jays or you could say his ridiculously MLB leading 24% HR/FB rate resulted in several of those BS as a fluke. WAR is there so you can simply put a value on a player, not to directly associate a player with a win today or a loss tomorrow. Travis being in the line up had nothing to do with the Jays losing games. It's a f***ing team sport and there is no reason why Ryan Goins should be playing over Travis when comparing the value each player provides to the team individually.
Did you know Kawasaki was in the Jays line up during 2013's 11 game winning streak? I guess we should start him over Travis too.