Well that's an extreme example of intent that could hurt someone and most definitely should be removed from the game. Hence the name "chase headley rule", going out of the range of the bag that could easily result in injury. Those are exactly the type of plays that don't belong in the game... For every play like that though there's 99 regular ones that don't need instant replay, automatic outs, suspensions, etc. when there is no risk of injury and otherwise is just part of the game.
No... even a contact sport like football you can't hit a receiver before he touches a ball... if a runner is sliding within range of a bag making an otherwise routine play of trying to break it up while there is no risk of injury to a fielder let it play out. It doesn't need a suspension or an extra automatic out. It's especially stupid when the infielders don't always do their part by stepping off to get out of the way but instead stay right on the bag. They don't get any push back for that.