Purcey is actually the year when the curse of the stolen pick began. And by that I don't necessarily mean that the Jays were in on the guys picked before them if they did slide, just that almost every year since then, a more valuable player was picked with the selection directly before the Jays.
2004
Pick 15: Diamondbacks select Stephen Drew
Pick 16: Blue Jays select David Purcey
2005
Pick 5: Brewers select Ryan Braun
Pick 6: Blue Jays Jays select Ricky Romero
*Note: This is also the year where Upton (1), Gordon (2), Zimmerman (4) and Tulowitzki (7) went in the top 7 picks. McCutchen (11), Bruce (12), Ellsbury (23), Garza (25) and Rasmus (28) also went in the first round.
2006
*This was the year where Tyler Colvin was drafted one pick before the Jays took Travis Snider, but this is no longer a "steal" in my book, considering Snider's resent "resurgence" (if you can call it that) and Colvin suddenly becoming s***. Note that both of these things happened after the curse was broken, so I assume that the curse is retroactively repairing some of the damage that it caused as a result. #RomeroReturns2015
2007
Pick 15: Reds select Devin Mesoraco
Pick 16: Blue Jays select Kevin Ahrens
2008
16 Overall: Brewers select Brett Lawrie
17 Overall: Blue Jays Jays select David Cooper
2009
19 Overall: Cardinals select Shelby Miller
20 Overall: Blue Jays select Chad Jenkins
Perhaps the bigger story here is that the Jays under Ricciardi were f***ing atrocious at drafting. Personally, I prefer the curse narrative.
The curse lost a step in its game in 2010 when the Jays threw away another pick on Deck McGuire, but the Athletics only got Michael "The Wrong" Choice with the prior selection. The next year (2011) the Jays lost Beede, and the following two years after that, the curse attempted a Pettittesque comeback, where Giolito was stolen before the Jays took DJ Davis, and Meadows was stolen before the Jays took Bickford.
Anthopoulos, unlike his predecessor as it was ultimately discovered, would not go down without a fight. With Andrew Tinnish at his side, and an onslaught of gyro meat in his arsenal, he would battle toe-to-toe with the curse - a legendary duel not unlike that of Gandalf and the balrog.
He'd scoff at the McGuire mishap by selecting Sanchez and Syndergaard with his next two selections. He'd make a mockery of the Beede blunder by selecting Norris in his stead. He'd drop a souvlaki-scented s*** on the Davis downer by taking Stroman five picks later.
The curse would finally fold in the fight against the fat Greek once and for all when Anthopoulos would wrest it to its knees by turning the previous year's Bickford bloop into a first round, 9th overall selection of future world series MVP and first ballot hall of famer, Jeff Hoffman. To ensure that the curse was down for good, the Colorado Rockies would draft garbage clown Kyle Freeland with the prior pick, and the Jays would select the reincarnation of Jason Kendall's dead father-in-law Bubba Joe Kendall, in Max Pentecost.
Disclaimer: If you actually read this whole post and are dissatisfied with its contents, only you are to blame. You should have known going into it that you were about to completely waste your time.