I do think they went a year to long but i also believe at the end of this contract its not going to look like a huge mistake either. I think he will average 1.5-2WAR per year. I also think that EE or his agent didn't give much thought to their 4 year offer and the jays saw it as he really didn't want to come back considering they were not going any higher. I think it would have been a huge risk to wait on EE and one i don't think many people would take.