I would not pay the 6 years he wants to keep him at third more or less because is body is not in the greatest shape ever (round) and i don't think he would hold up to a long term deal. If they move him to first however he would be alright but he has not OPS'd over .800 in a few years so that bat really does not play for the position. I think you could save the money and spend it somewhere else. Unless you get him on a four year deal (i doubt) then i would not really even consider it.