He's a great catcher,no question about that.
But when he's beat up, like he is now, he really isn't much of an offensive threat....Of course, he hit the homer yesterday and that's great, but he usually strikes out or hits into double plays.
Having said that, He has to be in the lineup whether he hits or not.....my problem is having Smoak bat fifth instead of Colabello.....the guy can't hit any breaking ball and why they ever give him a fast ball over the plate is a mystery to me.