Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account

Terminator

Old-Timey Member
  • Posts

    22,141
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    121

 Content Type 

Profiles

Toronto Blue Jays Videos

2026 Toronto Blue Jays Top Prospect Rankings

Toronto Blue Jays Trade & Free Agent Rumors

Toronto Blue Jays Fan Guides & Resources

2025 Toronto Blue Jays Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Toronto Blue Jays News, Rumors & Analysis

2026 Toronto Blue Jays Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Forums

Blogs

Events

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by Terminator

  1. You're on to something here!
  2. I should have added the amount of games. Player A is making 2 innings per appearance. Player B is just over 3. I also could have noted that Player A is now starting games after that performance in High A and that Player B is seen in the industry to carry both reliever and injury risk.
  3. You aren't wrong about those possibly being better options but this is my point. They must think Max Castillo is dogshit if these are the options they have. We are one injury away from Thornton bullpen games. 2 injuries away from Thornton Bullpen games followed by Casey Lawrence starts.
  4. Based on their age and High-A Stats? Other Notes: Player A made almost 2 innings per appearance. Player B is just over 3. Player A is now starting games and Player B is seen in the industry to carry both reliever and injury risk.
  5. Bullpen starts? 20 year old Tiedemann? Yikes...
  6. I bet Merrifield gets plenty of time at 2B. Espinal isn't anything special and has been playing pretty poorly for a while. Also, since the bench is stacked with lefties, Tapia and Biggio sometimes play more against lefties than they should and with Merrifield they won't ever have to.
  7. They must REALLY hate Max Castillo then if they think adding Merrifield is worth Lawrence/Hatch/etc. being next man up.
  8. So Stripling to the IL and White into the rotation. Who is next up for SP? Hatch?
  9. Mitch White: 27 years old and has a 3.58 ERA in 105 MLB Innings Nick Frasso: 24 years old and racking up Ks against a bunch of 19 year olds in A-Ball. Ranked outside our top 10 prospects by multiple organizations. BJMB: "OH MY GOD HOW DARE THEY TRADE FRASSO FOR MITCH WHITE!!!! FIRE ATKINS!!!!"
  10. Frasso was our number 13th ranked prospect according to Fangraphs updated list. What was Frasso's org ranking on the other updated lists? MLB Pipeline has him as the Dodgers 26th best prospect, what was he with us? Where did BA have him ranked? EDIT: Looks like he was our 13th best prospect on BA as well.
  11. He's a real prospect. We wouldn't have gotten Mitch White and Alex De Jesus (also a real prospect) for him if he wasn't. But he's got both injury and reliever risk and is old for his level (the non-prospects drag the average age up) so you have to take his stats in context. He also doesn't rank very high on any of the midseason prospect lists which take into account his dominating half season of A/A+ ball. It just seems like people think he's Tiedemann or Top 100 or something when he's not. He's very mid.
  12. s*** I just looked it up and Frasso is damn near 24. He's pitching against 19 year olds for crying out loud. If the guy tried dating girls that age he'd probably get arrested in some states but I'm supposed to be impressed that he struck out some kids whose balls just dropped? No thanks. Plus, I'm speaking from experience here. I'm 62 years young now but I didn't graduate high school until I was 21. Whenever I took the hill I would carve up those 16-18 year olds like they were a Christmas ham. It was easy, same thing applies with Frasso.
  13. Yeah true and after I posted I saw that this has already been discussed.
  14. Beasley stinks and was taking up a 40-man spot.
  15. Well what about White, Bass, Pop and Merrifield? Surely those guys are comparable talent-wise to the 4 you mentioned? I'm not sure what the Twins gave up either but my guess is they gave up a lot more.
  16. This is just full of doozies. Every time I read it I find another one. Pros: -Surprisingly he doesn't whine about losing Groshans. Cons: -Whit Merrifield is merely a "Bradley Zimmer replacement" -Claiming that a 23 year old A-ball pitcher was one of our best prospects. Buddy, if a 23 year old isn't dominating A-Ball then he isn't even a prospect. The Yanks just traded 3 Nick Frasso's and got a half season of slap hitting Benitendi. -Whines about losing said A-ball pitcher while making no mention of Alex De Jesus who ranks higher than Frasso on some prospect lists. -Uses literally one stat, strikeouts, to evaluate the entire deadline. -Claims that Max Castillo is a better strikeout pitcher than Mitch White based upon 20 big league innings for Castillo. (No projection system thinks Castillo will K more than White.) -Doesn't realize that Bass actually is a strikeout pitcher now because he throws his slider more. -Makes a big deal out of an extra season of control on Castillo over White but makes no mention of every single player we acquired having multiple seasons of control. -Makes no mention of it being a seller's market For the foregoing reasons, I'm going to have grade this post as an F for displaying such a heavy lack of knowledge of the game and an overall whiny attitude.
  17. Pros: -Mitch White looks like a legit backend starter. -Anthony Bass isn't a sexy pickup because he doesn't throw hard and he's old but he was one of the best relievers moved this year. -Pop has good potential he just needs to gain slider command. Even if he doesn't he's still very serviceable. -Merrifield is a very underrated pickup. He was a 3 WAR player last year and outside of a horrid April he's basically been that same guy. Good projections and the dude NEVER gets hurt. Picking up a durable and versatile 2-3 WAR player like this is a great move. -All 4 of these guys are under control and cheap for next year or beyond. The 2023 Blue Jays are just as good from this deadline as the 2022 Blue Jays are. -Alex De Jesus is an actual prospect at a position that we develop pretty well. -We really didn't give up s***. A slap hitting Former Top 100 prospect that is falling fast, Max Castillo a guy who has had 20 good innings after a mediocre minor league career and a 23 year old A-ball pitcher. Cons: -We added White over Castillo which is an upgrade to our pitching depth but it's razor thin and we did the bare minimum to address it. -I would have liked to have seen one more impact player added, probably a starting pitcher, by trading Moreno. I think the problem is that a lot of the impact players were moved by teams that already have young Catchers in place so we just weren't able to lineup. In the offseason perhaps we deal Jansen or Moreno.
  18. ^This guy thought Greg Bird (currently hitting .218 for Scranton LMAO) was a big league talent so take his talent evaluation with a HEAVY dose of salt.
  19. Roster Resource has White in AAA right now. If they bring him up to the big league team they could option Collins or DFA Zimmer.
  20. Lol he does sound better.
  21. He's a fringe prospect but there is enough there to call him a prospect still.
  22. Lol ok Mr. "Hey Sweetie, It's Ross"
  23. Merrifield's stats are ugly but his peripherals aren't nearly as bad. The Royals are also a s*** org and the Jays a good one so maybe they can fix something to get some more juice out of him. Castillo looked good so far but he has no track record and doesn't project that well. He's very hard to stat scout which is what most of us are doing. My guess is he's a guy classically overrated by fans compared to front offices simply because we don't have as much data.
  24. Yeah the biggest things we needed were relievers and starting pitching depth. We got the relievers in one trade and added the depth in White. White becomes our #6 SP with Kikuchi being a very shaky #5. I thought Castillo slotted in nicely as the #7. But now he's gone and Hatch is the #7? Yikes.
  25. But White is a better asset than Thor (impending FA) and Iglesias (expensive as hell) combined.
×
×
  • Create New...