jaysblue

You don't let get Stripling get shelled. If he gives up a hard hit or leadoff walk, then you make the call to the bullpen.

Jay, at 81 pitches, Stripling could have went out in the 6th and if he gave up a hard hit ball or walk, pull him. Geez, even in 2005 guys like Josh Tower and Gustavo Chacin pitched deep into games if they were cruising and pitching well. Given how awful the Jays bullpen is, they need to ask a bit extra from their starters and Stripling was more than fine going out in the 6th on a short leash.

Sometimes when you have a starter dealing, if you could squeeze an extra inning out of him (especially after only FIVE innings), and especially considering the Blue Jays bullpen, wouldn't have been a bad idea. I understand in the Postseason or if the Jays were deep with solid bullpen arms that you could rely on to give you 4 innings to close out a game, though that isn't the case. It wouldn't have been the end of the world sending Stripling out in the 6th inning at only 81 pitches and keep him on a short leash. If he was closer to 100 pitches and had a lot of high stress situations, different story. Also, Stripling in June has posted a 1.16 ERA in his 5 starts. It's not like he's been awful or anything.

Tomi Lahren is pretty hot.

You could even make the argument Goldy has been better than Votto and Freeman. Goldy has been pretty much durable throughout his career and I think now he's found a comfort level with the Cardinals. Barring any devastating injury or drastic dropoff, Goldy should still produce in his age 35-40 seasons.

Goldy has been one of the most underrated superstars in baseball the past decade. He's having a masterful season that isn't getting talked about as much as it should.

This is probably the best core the Leafs have had in the past two decades. A lot better than the Leafs in late 90s and early 2000s, when you had Sundin, Mogilny, Gary Roberts, Tucker, Thomas etc. If they can't win a Stanley Cup with the core they have, which I think on paper looks like one of the best in the league, it's going to extremely tough to draft and develop another top core again. The waiting game will continue. Do you give the Leafs another season with this core to see how far they can go, or do you shakeup something by trading one of Matthews, Marner, Taveras or Nylander for another superstar caliber guy?

I thought the Leafs in 2002 could have went all the way. They met the Hurricanes in the Eastern Conference Finals after beating the Islanders and Devils (their Kryptonite that decade). Red Wings would have likely beat them that season, though still the furthest the Leafs have gone in the longest times. Leafs could use a top goalie who could carry them in the Playoffs. Miss the days of Joseph and Balfour.

If the Jays give him a short leash, no problem with this signing at all. He posted a 1.0 WAR in 2019.

They had a fantastic season yes, though playoff hockey is a different type of animal. With an elite core of Matthews, Taveras, Marner, Nylander, they haven't even been able to get by the first round. If the Leafs can't win a Stanley Cup in the next one or two years with these guys in their prime, they never will.

No Canadian team has won the Stanley Cup since the Habs in 1993. Canucks came close last decade, though that's about it.

Leafs went blow for blow with Montreal last season and Boston the previous years and could have easily been in their place as well. But they weren't.

Trading for a solid bullpen arm or two or signing them via free agency wouldn't have hindered their future for the next 3 to 4 years in terms of depleting the farm system or taking up a huge portion of their spending budget. Where did I suggest they go out and trade/sign superstar and expensive talent? Solidifying the bullpen won't break the bank or deplete the farm system.

That's a shame! I remember when everyone at first on here were jumping for joy that some players or pitchers weren't able to play in Toronto when the Yankees and Boston came to town and thought what a huge advantage for the Blue Jays. Quite the opposite haha. I'm still sure they could have improved the bullpen whether through free agency or through trade.

As a front office, you have to prepare for injuries during the season and the great teams have that depth to replace those players when injuries happen and don't lose much of a beat. Look at teams like the Yankees and Rays. It's easy to say "with everyone at full health." The Jays lineup at full health is amazing though when you start losing a big piece or two, it becomes weak very quickly especially when you have guys filling out the bench who are below replacement level who you just picked up at the end of Spring Training. One of Espinal and Biggio on the bench (Biggio struggled and was in the minors earlier so the Jays never had him as an option) along with one of Jansen/Moreno as the second catcher is a great start will give you that. Tapia has been played way too much obviously though that is because of injuries and mismanagement. He still has produced a -0.8 WAR so he's hurting the Jays more every time he is out there! The Bradley Zimmer project should have ended weeks ago and its crazy to imagine he still has a roster spot. It's crazy this team couldn't find a reliable 4th outfielder during the offseason. Filling out the bench or bullpen shouldn't be that difficult during the offseason.

Schwarber would be a nice fit in the Jays lineup as a DH/1B/LF bat. If the Phillies want to get rid of his contract, probably can get him at a fair price.

What time is it meat?

Depends on if we're talking about elite guys at all those positions or middle tier/average guys just to fill holes on the roster. Adding a top arm that is a solid No. 2 or 3 starter, along with two elite relievers and an above average left-handed bat is a lot. It's not impossible, though you would be digging a lot into the farm system. Also, the Yankees, Red Sox, Rays and other teams will be buyers most likely as well. Like you said, the Jays will be locks at making the Postseason, so definitely they will be buyers. Atkins has been active at trade deadlines the previous two seasons buying, so this season won't be any different IMO. Though the Jays can't go after broken down projects and expect that will be enough. Hope they get a player or arm or both that could push the team over the top.

That's a big shopping list. If the Blue Jays front office actually spent time in the offseason looking at the bench and bullpen, maybe at the trade deadline the Jays could have mainly focused on bringing in a big bat or big arm. Instead, we're talking about filling 4 or 5 holes on this roster which is a lot at the trade deadline.

The Jays could use another left-handed bat who is actually decent + a top starter + 2 or 3 elite BP arms. Yikes, that is a shopping list! We were talking about Josh Bell in April/May, and that was before the need for a top starter and BP arms.

Leafs could never play this caliber of hockey like Tampa and Colorado. The Leafs still have a long way to go until they become true Stanley Cup contenders.

Jonathan Villar available. Hired William from LOD as an agent to trade him. Giving him a 20% cut if he finds a suitor.

Over a 162 game season, if you don't have a strong bullpen, you need your top starters to go deep into games, even if that means having them throw 100-110 pitches. It's not going to kill them. That's why a starter like Roy Halladay was so valuable. You knew even on his bad days (maybe he gives up 4ER), he would give you 6 or 7 innings and save the bullpen. In the Postseason, you definitely can manage differently. You can shorten the game for starting pitchers and use your elite BP arms two games in a row, knowing they will have an off-day and be rested for Game 3.

I love Tampa and they're one of my favourite organizations though what works in Tampa doesn't repeat and work for all the remaining 29 teams. Not every team will have a deep bullpen and deep system of arms who they can call up and rely on over 162 games.

Yeah sorry about the Burnett addition, his 2008 season was at the back of my mind when mentioning him. Doc and him were such a fantastic 1-2 punch and workhorses that season. Should have used Oswalt instead haha.