Exactly! I've yet to hear a compelling argument regarding him being capable of taking the team to the next level because he's pretty much proven that he can't! By his own admission we've been all-in for 3 years now and during that time he's handed starting jobs to guys like JPA, Bonifacio, Goins, Dustin McGowan and not to mention the 6 rookies from this year... And pretty much all those decisions were made without a contingency in place in case they fail. He's lucky that Pillar has emerged as a semi decent everyday player or else we would be looking at Bautista as the only major league OF on the team. But ya, he's made the Donaldson trade and he's not the worst GM so let's keep him around for another 6 years...
If you've actually watched him in action over the past 3 years and still think that the circumstances out of his control have led to the losing record, then I don't know what to tell you.
Deadpool is dead wrong! I actually think he gets far too much credit for his drafting/development because of who he has replaced. JPR was never given the same flexibility that AA enjoys, having a much bigger budget and the opportunity to grab higher ceiling high-school kids. Besides, what good are prospects if you don't hold on to the best ones and instead use them mostly as currency to acquire aging veterans.
I also think he gets too much credit for his "shrewd trades" since he has been under very little pressure to make most of those moves. He does deserve some credit of course but it's hard to dismiss the fact that he was mostly dealing from a position of strength making deals that he didn't have to make. Even the Donaldson trade wasn't a move he had to make since he was already very comfortable with Lawrie at 3B. The only somewhat shrewd move he's made that has actually addressed a direct need was the Travis trade and even that came at the expense of sacrificing OF depth. The rest of the moves, like the Lawrie for marcum trade, are not moves most GMs can afford to make since it temporarily weakens their big league roster.
And those insane extensions aren't something a GM can build a career on since after a few, the agents catch up to the fact that he's a tightwad and will refuse to negotiate with him exclusively in the future. It's definitely not something he'd want to build a reputation on and besides, what good are those extensions if he ends up trading assets for someone like Reyes and strap himself financially away?