While your assessments of me are usually correct and maybe I will stir the pot with IKF on occasion, I genuinely hated the signing. My dislike of limp noodle bats with only their defense as a a redeeming quality is documented. It’s understandable you can’t have all star bats everywhere, even on good teams, and you’ll have to find a guy on the cheap to fill that role even on good teams (or just do that internally)
You can’t really cry about the glass half empty crowd. Jays are a playoff team, they’re Canada’s only team, they have expectations like other playoff teams. They went into the playoffs limping on offense and they got booted the same way. They didn’t do anything to address it. Turner is a downgrade from Belt and is a high risk to bust at 39. IKF is a huge downgrade from last year offensively. Question Urshela is fine but at least there’s legit offensive upside there. Not to mention they doubled down on the OF scenario of committing to Varsho as a corner OF when his bat didn’t come close to playing there last year
Not only the IKF salary, but they have him two years, which was completely unnecessary. It may not prevent them from going after a big name next year, but it took up a spot for a legit upside flyer they may pass up next year and they committed for the next two years to downgrade their offense. So that’s the legit glass half empty
Now, you can do the glass half full thing and say there’s reason to believe some guys are going to bounce back. There’s merit to that but it’s not like it’s the only way one can think of they’re just stupid