Over the last four years vs RHP:
2013 (SSS): .391 wOBA
2012: .343 wOBA
2011: .330 wOBA
2010: .357 wOBA
Career numbers are obviously skewed upward by that great 2009 year. Being a defensive liability, he is clearly not worth the money (especially with how tight our payroll will be).
But if he keeps this up over a full season it's not the biggest tragedy if the options get picked up. Whatever.
Fool me once, shame on you. Foool me twice, shame on me.