I'm trying to think of someone who has lost as much potential earnings as Bautista, based off of timing.
If he becomes a free agent with two season of breakout performance instead of one, he probably makes a lot more than 5/$65 million.
If he becomes a free agent immediately after the bat flip season, instead of a year later, he probably has no trouble getting a big multi-year deal.
One year of free agent timing on either side of his peak years is going to cost him a lot of money.
That said, with the Booster Juice money rolling in, he's probably still doing okay.