http://mkjon.es/gifs/facepalm_jack_nickelson.gif
Me, reading one horrific take after another in this thread.
A trade doesn't have to be a win or a loss, guys. And in this case, the Jays made out fine. Sim is about as good of a pitching prospect as there is below AA. He possesses premium velocity with multiple plus secondaries. He has the size (currently 6'3"/210 lbs.) and is still only 18. By the way, he has absolutely dominated A level ball in a way that very few pitchers have in the past 15 years. This is comparable to getting a Deivi Garcia or Luis Patino at the same level, and he probably ascends the minors more quickly than expected. He could be contributing at some point late in 2021 or, perhaps more likely, by mid-2022.
Anthony Kay has some good stuff, too. He's basically big-league ready now, as you can just throw AAA numbers right out the f***ing window, thanks to the ball change they made this year. His ceiling might be a #3, though he's more likely a backend/depth guy, or maybe he thrives in a relief role. The curveball/fastball combo here is pretty bonkers, though. If he can find his changeup again, maybe he could become that mid-rotation starter.
It's not a great trade and it's not an awful trade - it's somewhere in between that. Personally, I'd probably rank it about a B-.
Can we at least wait to see how the rest of the deadline deals play out before we call for Atkins' head?