Go back and read posts here when he was still productive. The Cruz and Ortiz comps flowed like Leaf fan tears after a playoff series against Boston. Posters were convinced that his great plate discipline, work ethic, and physical condition would lead to extended productivity into his late 30s, and then it didn't happen at all.
I'd actually be quite happy with a Stro extension, but expecting him to age particularly well because of his work ethic is silly.