Whatever the ump calls probably. Our outfielders could have made a production out of trying to grab it and it being stuck, then magically coming up with it. That probably would have worked.
I think part of the interesting flavor of this league is the flex roster capability, which we'd lose by making it permanently 14. It probably really only needs to apply to the cut downs though.
Is there any actual upside to limiting the farms in between cut downs? It might make things more interesting not to. People would still have to cut down twice a year.