Okay trade scenario for me in an auction keeper 5 x 5 roto pool. I am tied for first in HR's, with a 15 HR drop to 3rd. I am 1st in RBI's with again only two guys anywhere near my league. I am 3rd in BA with 4 guys close behind me, and I'm in 4th in runs with only an immediate chance to move up and not down. SB's are not a factor for me.
Trade is me trading EE for Goldschmidt.
Details are Goldschmidt is a $11 4th year contract which means upon receiving him he's locked in as a keeper for me at a value of $16 and he'll be back in the auction the following year. Edwin is a 3rd year contact $19 which means I could keep him for $24...but that is the last year I could keep him. I can next year trade him in a similar situation to what the other guy is doing with Goldy.
Part of me just thinks I can stand pat, go with Edwin and nothing will change. But then the guy deals Goldy to a competitor.
ZIPS has Goldy with an edge in every stat except HR's (20 to 18)
Should probably also note that it's approximately $800 for 1st and $400 for 2nd. So this year does have some extra weight to it.