solid defensively and it's a position of short-term need, short term. Guy is praised as a max effort, highly coachable type. I tend to find those guys need less minor league time anyway so when they use up an option sending him back down (which I assume is their intention) it could work out that in 4 years he's out of options but still shows upside then it's a huge roster management error but I don't see it as bad as wasting an option on a pitcher. It's still a little shocking but it's probably not the most egregious error they've made.