What the Blue Jays Can Learn From Every Team in the 2026 MLB Playoffs

[Sam Charles]

There's a reason baseball plays 162 regular season games. Over six months, flaws are exposed, depth is tested and the most complete teams usually rise to the top.

Heading into 2026, the Toronto Blue Jays appeared poised for another playoff run and perhaps some redemption after their Game 7 World Series loss the previous year. Instead, they finished 79-83 and last in the American League East, a stunning reversal from their 2025 pennant-winning season.

The offence collapsed. Toronto scored just 648 runs, the fewest in Major League Baseball. The Jays also ranked last in home runs (152), 26th in on-base percentage (.310) and 29th in slugging percentage (.381). The pitching staff held up considerably better, finishing among the league's better run-prevention units despite a relentless wave of injuries.

The 12 playoff teams who reached this year’s postseason did so through different methods. Some relied on stars, some on depth and others on elite player development. There is no single formula for success, but there are lessons to be learned.

The Blue Jays do not need to become the Dodgers, Brewers or Rays. Instead, they’ll undoubtedly study what those teams did to build rosters capable of winning.

Toronto's 2025 club had a clear identity. It got on base, made contact and created pressure throughout the lineup.

In 2026, much of that disappeared.

The Blue Jays remained difficult to strike out and finished ninth in batting average, but the contact often produced little damage. They finished last in runs, last in home runs and near the bottom of the league in slugging percentage.

The best teams in baseball weren't dependent on a single strength. The Dodgers paired elite offensive talent with frontline pitching. The Yankees combined power with strong run prevention. The Brewers won with depth, versatility and outstanding pitching. Tampa Bay, as they normally do, relied on organizational depth and player development. Even teams with obvious flaws generally possessed enough strengths elsewhere to compensate.

When the Blue Jays' offence disappeared in 2025, there was no fallback. Unless Brett Bateman's energy counted as an emergency offensive strategy, the club rarely had an answer when its primary strengths vanished.

Championship contenders are rarely perfect, just like the 2025 Jays. Those teams are simply built to withstand adversity better than everyone else.

The Dodgers remain the gold standard for a reason. Their roster is loaded with impact players capable of changing a game at any moment. Concentrating elite talent raises both a team's floor and its ceiling. When one star struggles, another often fills the void. That approach also costs a lot of money.

The Blue Jays already spend like a large-market team. They do not need to match Los Angeles player for player, but they do need more impact from the top of their roster.

At the same time, the Brewers demonstrated that depth can be a competitive advantage.

Milwaukee entered October following the best regular season in franchise history with a roster built on versatility and quality pitching. It probably doesn't hurt that visiting hitters occasionally seem convinced the roof at American Family Field has Gold Glove-calibre range.

Toronto's depth looked adequate entering the season, but injuries exposed just how thin that margin can be. At least 28 players spent time on the injured list.

No team can completely prepare for that level of attrition. However, the best organizations continually replenish talent and avoid becoming overly dependent on a small group of players.

The lesson is not to choose between stars and depth. The lesson is that contenders need both.

No organization illustrates depth better than the Rays. Tampa Bay won the AL East with a 98-64 record despite operating under dramatically different financial constraints than Toronto. Year after year, the Rays identify value, develop players and replace departing contributors without dramatically changing their competitiveness.

The Blue Jays do not need to adopt Tampa Bay's financial model, but there is value in emulating its ability to continuously generate contributors.

Contending teams need inexpensive players capable of filling meaningful roles. They need prospects who can step into the lineup. They need a development pipeline that reduces the need to solve every problem through free agency.

To their credit, Toronto appears to be moving in that direction through recent drafts and acquisitions. The challenge now is continuing to create opportunities for those players.

The Yankees offered another important reminder this season. Although they reached October as a wild-card club, they possessed one of the strongest run differentials among American League playoff teams. They backed that up by dominating Boston in the opening round.

Over a full season, run differential tends to reveal how strong a team actually is. Good teams do not spend six months surviving one-run games and bullpen escapes. They consistently outplay opponents and build separation on the scoreboard.

Toronto finished with a minus-46 run differential, scoring 648 runs while allowing 694.

The Blue Jays pitched well enough to remain competitive in many games, but they simply did not score enough. Pitching can keep a team afloat, but offensive shortcomings eventually catch up.

The Cubs and Guardians demonstrated opposite versions of the same lesson.

Cleveland reached the postseason despite offensive limitations because its pitching staff provided a strong foundation. Toronto can relate to that. Despite the disappointing season, the Blue Jays still finished with a respectable 3.90 ERA. Dylan Cease was especially outstanding, posting a 2.40 ERA with 239 strikeouts in 169 innings.

The Cubs arrived in October with one of baseball's better offences but legitimate questions on the mound despite the addition of Kevin Gausman. Those concerns quickly surfaced during their brief postseason appearance.

The takeaway for Toronto is straightforward: No single strength can cover every weakness indefinitely.

Putting the ball in play cannot permanently offset a lack of power. Great pitching cannot fully compensate for one of baseball's weakest offences. Strong bullpens cannot rescue every close game. The deeper teams advance into October, the more complete they tend to be.

The playoff field offered many different models for success, but several consistent themes emerged.

First, Toronto needs another legitimate middle-of-the-order hitter.

Second, the organization needs Vladimir Guerrero Jr. to return to being a foundational offensive force.

Third, adding at least one dependable starting pitcher should remain a priority. Cease gives the Blue Jays an ace, but the injuries of 2026 demonstrated the danger of relying on optimistic health projections.

Fourth, Toronto needs a deeper and more versatile bench capable of surviving inevitable injuries.

Fifth, the club should continue giving younger players meaningful opportunities to earn roles.

Sixth, roster additions should complement existing strengths and weaknesses. Another contact-oriented hitter would only reinforce an existing imbalance. This lineup needs more power and more on-base ability.

Finally, the Blue Jays should preserve what worked. Run prevention remained respectable despite extensive injuries. Cease emerged as a frontline starter. Okamoto delivered 33 home runs. Several younger players showed promise.

The task is to repair the roster, not demolish it.

The Blue Jays fell from fourth in MLB in runs scored in 2025 to last in 2026. They lost more than power. They lost on-base ability, lineup depth and the capacity to absorb underperformance. Injuries then attacked the pitching depth that might otherwise have kept them competitive.

This year's playoff teams showed there is more than one route back to contention. The most important lesson from October is not that the Blue Jays need to become the Dodgers, Brewers or Rays. It is that championship teams are built to remain dangerous when things go wrong.

Toronto's 2026 team wasn't. Its next roster must be.

View full article