AA's 2010 Draft Review

[Atothe]

Deck McGuire RHP R / R 6' 6" 220 06/23/1989 1 11 08/16/2010

Aaron Sanchez RHP R / R 6' 4" 200 07/01/1992 CA 34 06/15/2010

Noah Syndergaard RHP L / R 6' 6" 240 08/29/1992 CA 38 06/15/2010

Asher Wojciechowski RHP R / R 6' 4" 240 12/21/1988 CA 41 06/16/2010

Griffin Murphy LHP R / L 6' 3" 230 01/16/1991 2 61 08/16/2010

Kellen Sweeney 3B L / R 6' 0" 180 09/14/1991 2 69 07/26/2010

Justin Nicolino LHP L / L 6' 3" 190 11/22/1991 2 80 08/09/2010

Chris Hawkins SS L / R 6' 2" 195 08/17/1991 3 93 06/15/2010

Marcus Knecht LF R / R 6' 1" 200 06/21/1990 CB 113 06/15/2010

Sam Dyson RHP R / R 6' 1" 205 05/07/1988 4 126 08/16/2010

Dickie Joe Thon SS R / R 6' 2" 185 11/16/1991 5 156 08/16/2010

Sean Nolin LHP L / L 6' 4" 230 12/26/1989 6 186 07/23/2010

Mitchell Taylor LHP L / L 6' 0" 155 05/11/1992 7 216 08/09/2010

Logan Ehlers LHP L / L 6' 1" 190 10/30/1991 8 246 Unsigned

Brandon Mims 2B S / R 5' 11" 180 06/18/1992 9 276 08/09/2010

Tyler Shreve RHP R / R 6' 4" 215 09/15/1991 10 306 Unsigned

Shane Opitz SS L / R 6' 1" 180 01/10/1992 11 336 07/31/2010

Omar Cotto CF S / R 5' 11" 180 02/28/1992 12 366 Unsigned

Tyler Painton LHP L / L 6' 5" 195 02/20/1992 13 396 Unsigned

Dayton Marze RHP R / R 6' 2" 185 01/01/1989 14 426 06/17/2010

Zak Adams LHP L / L 6' 2" 190 03/19/1992 15 456 08/16/2010

Dalton Pompey CF S / R 6' 2" 195 12/11/1992 16 486 06/17/2010

Myles Jaye RHP S / R 6' 3" 170 12/28/1991 17 516 08/16/2010

Kris Bryant 3B R / R 6' 5" 215 01/04/1992 18 546 Unsigned

Travis Garrett RHP R / R 5' 11" 205 10/27/1989 19 576 06/15/2010

Art Charles LHP L / L 6' 6" 220 11/10/1990 20 606 07/06/2010

Chris Marlowe RHP R / R 6' 0" 175 10/26/1989 21 636 Unsigned

Aaron Westlake LF L / R 6' 4" 235 12/27/1988 22 666 Unsigned

Angel Gomez RF S / R 6' 2" 180 01/12/1992 23 696 06/15/2010

Ronnie Melendez CF R / R 5' 10" 170 09/29/1989 24 726 06/15/2010

Brando Tessar RHP R / R 6' 1" 190 05/13/1991 25 756 Unsigned

Jay Johnson LHP R / L 6' 2" 210 12/21/1989 26 786 Unsigned

Eric Arce C L / R 5' 9" 205 11/29/1991 27 816 Unsigned

Adaric Kelly RHP R / R 5' 10" 180 12/01/1992 28 846 Unsigned

Jonathan Jones RF R / R 5' 11" 185 08/02/1989 29 876 06/20/2010

Steve McQuail 2B R / R 6' 2" 225 06/10/1989 30 906 06/15/2010

Luis Benitez RHP S / R 6' 3" 195 05/24/1992 31 936 Unsigned

Andy Fermin 2B L / R 6' 0" 180 07/27/1989 32 966 06/15/2010

Melvin Garcia OF R / R 6' 0" 175 09/17/1991 33 996 06/30/2010

Tyler Powell RHP R / R 6' 4" 210 02/16/1989 34 1026 06/15/2010

Danny Barnes RHP L / R 6' 1" 195 10/21/1989 35 1056 06/15/2010

David Whitehead RHP R / R 6' 4" 215 04/21/1992 36 1086 Unsigned

Chad Green RHP L / R 6' 3" 210 05/24/1991 37 1116 Unsigned

Pierce Rankin LF R / R 6' 1" 190 04/26/1989 38 1146 06/20/2010

Nick Vander Tuig RHP R / R 6' 3" 190 12/09/1991 39 1176 Unsigned

Brandon Berl RHP R / R 6' 0" 185 04/09/1988 40 1206 06/15/2010

Seth Conner IF R / R 6' 2" 205 01/29/1992 41 1236 Unsigned

Drew Permison RHP R / R 5' 10" 170 02/24/1989 42 1266 06/15/2010

Ron Schreurs LHP L / L 6' 6" 205 07/14/1992 43 1296 Unsigned

Mott Hyde 2B R / R 5' 10" 190 03/10/1992 44 1326 Unsigned

Philip Diedrick LF L / R 6' 1" 210 09/17/1992 45 1356 Unsigned

Connor Smith RHP R / R 6' 2" 210 06/12/1992 46 1386 Unsigned

Gabriel Romero RHP R / R 5' 10" 150 11/13/1992 47 1416 Unsigned

Nick Studer C R / R 6' 3" 225 10/23/1992 48 1446 Unsigned

Matt Abraham 2B R / R 5' 8" 165 01/27/1987 49 1476 06/15/2010

Kelly Norris-Jones C R / R 5' 11" 175 03/17/1992 50 1506 Unsigned

Edited October 11, 2014 by Atothe

[Atothe]

Successes-

Sanchez, Pompey, Sydergaard, Nicolino, Bryant, Nolin, Dyson.

 

Failures-

Everyone else.

 

Do you believe that group of players that are successes are enough to make this draft an overall success?

 

Edit: Bolded names have made their mlb debuts

Edited October 11, 2014 by Atothe

[GNick49]

Still too early...needs 5 years minimum for proper evaluation.

[Atothe]

What do you consider to be "successful"? None of those players have been successful yet except Sanchez as a reliever. And Nicolino kind of sucks.

 

But he'll make it to the mlb I believe, as starter (spot or otherwise). I define success as making to the mlb.

[Atothe]

Still too early...needs 5 years minimum for proper evaluation.

 

Not with the criteria of just making to the mlb.

[RealAccountant]

Way too early,

[GD]

"Kris Bryant" SIGHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

[SAAviour]

I like these threads. But I didn't vote on this one, too early.

[Atothe]

Besides who myself and King pointed out, who else will make the majors from that list?

[ElNik2013]

Besides who myself and King pointed out, who else will make the majors from that list?

 

 

McGuire still has a chance to make it as a long reliever. Same way you included Chad Jenkins in your 2009 poll. You failed to include Syndergaard, Nicolino, Wojciechowski and Bryant as well, or at least you didn't highlight their names.

[Atothe]

McGuire still has a chance to make it as a long reliever. Same way you included Chad Jenkins in your 2009 poll. You failed to include Syndergaard, Nicolino, Wojciechowski and Bryant as well, or at least you didn't highlight their names.

 

Because those guys haven't played an mlb game yet

[burlingtonbandit]

Because those guys haven't played an mlb game yet

 

So how do you call them failures?

[ElNik2013]

Because those guys haven't played an mlb game yet

 

 

Ok, I see. Like others have said, we'll have to wait a bit longer since guys like Bryant, Syndergaard plus a few others could make it next year.

 

Hopefully, Brad Glenn and Ryan Goins have played their last MLB games from the 2009 list.

[Angrioter]

Successes-

Sanchez, Pompey, Sydergaard, Nicolino, Bryant, Nolin, Dyson.

 

Failures-

Everyone else.

 

Do you believe that group of players that are successes are enough to make this draft an overall success?

 

Edit: Bolded names have made their mlb debuts

 

Jays 2nd best draft in years (#1 Hoffman, Reid-Foley, Pentecost, Thomas, Wells)

[Atothe]

So how do you call them failures?

 

Who are you talking about specifically because everyone I named in the success column did or is gonna make the majors. Everyone has the odds stacked against them.