Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted
I have had countless arguements with people who think every stadium in baseball should have the same dimensions so they all play the same. Like all the other team sports. They don't understand that playing in a different climate will effect the way the ball travels. It is also one of the great unique things about baseball seeing how different every ballpark really is.

 

How utterly boring, reminds me of most other sports.

Posted
You could argue that the dimensions in baseball are limitless. Theoretically, as long as your ball is between the foul poles, it is fair, even it it goes all the way to China. There is also no theoretical limit on the time of a game. A tie game could theoretically go on for years. Baseball is infinite both in time and space.
Posted
Exactly. For some reason they feel its unfair and the Yankees and Red Sox are cheating.

 

 

It's actually in the rulebook that no ballpark that was created beyond 1968 or something (forgot) cannot have a wall below 320'. Yankees have 2 (left and right field). In a way, it is cheating to play in that park 81 times a year.

Posted
It's actually in the rulebook that no ballpark that was created beyond 1968 or something (forgot) cannot have a wall below 320'. Yankees have 2 (left and right field). In a way, it is cheating to play in that park 81 times a year.

 

Cheating would be hitting in that park and pitching in another.

Posted
Cheating would be hitting in that park and pitching in another.

 

Cheating is building a park that is in blatant violation of the rules. Y'know, like Yankee stadium.

 

And Fenway is still a shithole.

Posted
I think they made an exception because they wanted it to be just like the old stadium.

 

Which is a s***** reason to give them an exception. The only valid reason I could possibly think of is "there isn't enough space to build a stadium with these dimensions..." and even then, they'd have to have a great reason for not finding a different location.

 

If old Yankee stadium was such a historic place, why is it a parking lot now?

Old-Timey Member
Posted
Which is a s***** reason to give them an exception. The only valid reason I could possibly think of is "there isn't enough space to build a stadium with these dimensions..." and even then, they'd have to have a great reason for not finding a different location.

 

If old Yankee stadium was such a historic place, why is it a parking lot now?

 

Because all good things must come to an end. It was old and needed to be replaced.

 

I hate the Yanks as much as the next guy but I get this. And I highly doubt it's caused much of an issue.

Posted
Cheating would be hitting in that park and pitching in another.

 

No you are wrong. You can certainly design a team that maximizes the effect of playing 81 games in the same park.

Posted
Which is a s***** reason to give them an exception. The only valid reason I could possibly think of is "there isn't enough space to build a stadium with these dimensions..." and even then, they'd have to have a great reason for not finding a different location.

 

If old Yankee stadium was such a historic place, why is it a parking lot now?

 

If you were there in the last few years of its existence you'd realize it didn't have anything close to a historical feel. It felt like a ballpark built in the 70's (reno). Sitting with the "creatures" though, a 2nd to nothing fan experience.

 

Tiger Stadium had a historical feel..... Fenway has a historical feel. I was just at Wrigley for the 100th anniversary game and that doesn't feel all that historical. McDonald's & other fast food joints around the park, just doesn't feel right.

Posted
If you were there in the last few years of its existence you'd realize it didn't have anything close to a historical feel. It felt like a ballpark built in the 70's (reno). Sitting with the "creatures" though, a 2nd to nothing fan experience.

 

Tiger Stadium had a historical feel..... Fenway has a historical feel. I was just at Wrigley for the 100th anniversary game and that doesn't feel all that historical. McDonald's & other fast food joints around the park, just doesn't feel right.

 

My point is that it WASN'T historic. Which was the excuse given for copying the (illegal) dimension...

 

Because all good things must come to an end. It was old and needed to be replaced.

 

I hate the Yanks as much as the next guy but I get this. And I highly doubt it's caused much of an issue.

 

It was a rhetorical question. It's a parking lot because it was just a generic stadium, not some sort of landmark that needed to be duplicated.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Blue Jays community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...