If you were GM, would you sign Garza?

[SAAviour]

These polls are tough cause there are so many factors to influence the decision, but try to ignore the other noise and look just at the transaction. If Garza's agent called you as GM and said you can match 4/$52 for Garza, would you take it or leave it.

[eastcoastjaysfan]

For 4/52?

 

Sure why not

[SAAviour]

I'm assuming his medical a checked out, so I say yes.

[Sammy225]

Depends on a lot of s***. I would initially say no because he can get a more reliable pitcher in Jimenez for the same amount of years might have to go 5 for not a whole lot more annually.

[Brenner]

The stats probably say yes, but I'll let someone else figure that out. But I say no, I don't trust the arm, the duct tape holding his arm on is about to fall off.

[z3r0s]

Medical = ok - good. yes

Medical say his arm will fall off next year. no.

 

Impossible to judge this one from the outside looking in. I really like Garza in a vacuum.

[JaysAllMighty]

Depends on a lot of s***. I would initially say no because he can get a more reliable pitcher in Jimenez for the same amount of years might have to go 5 for not a whole lot more annually.

 

+1, agree

[FireAlexAnthopoulos]

No... but I also wouldn't have made the disastrous panic trades that made it so that missing out on Garza would be so detrimental.