Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted
I'm just excited to see his Chopper when it's all finished. I bet it'll have rocket launchers on it. He'll be able to parachute out of it and land on the field!

 

So it's okay for Will Ferrell but not ok for Poo-eeg. Racism at its finest.

Posted
So it's okay for Will Ferrell but not ok for Poo-eeg. Racism at its finest.

 

I saw no implication that TCA thinks it's not OK, my little SJW buddy

Posted
So it's okay for Will Ferrell but not ok for Poo-eeg. Racism at its finest.

 

I know, right! Ferrell didn't have to parachute out of his, he got to land. But as soon as a Cuban wants to do it, no, not allowed, he has to jump.

Community Moderator
Posted
I don't really agree with that. He has a career .374 wOBA over 1300 PAs thru age 25. You would gladly take that from any hitting prospect if you could. Last year was a disaster according to most people, and he was still an above average hitter who put up 1.5 WAR in half a season. The level of hatred for him is disproportionate to his talent.

 

You state facts, but even with the lovely wOBAs he was a guy that couldn't find it in himself to yank 20 over the fence, and he's probably done stealing double digit bases. There's some inherent risk in the basic statistical profile in a fantasy sense. No idea what type of player he will be production wise. All we really know is that he has a special hitting ability and obviously some raw juice - which is all that can be said about a lot of top hitting prospects, like his teammate C.Seags.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
You state facts, but even with the lovely wOBAs he was a guy that couldn't find it in himself to yank 20 over the fence, and he's probably done stealing double digit bases. There's some inherent risk in the basic statistical profile in a fantasy sense. No idea what type of player he will be production wise. All we really know is that he has a special hitting ability and obviously some raw juice - which is all that can be said about a lot of top hitting prospects, like his teammate C.Seags.

 

This was my biggest hangup on how to value my offer. Never did reconcile it before the deal was done.

Community Moderator
Posted
The most interesting thing about Puig is that some people (JFaS) are comfortable saying that he outright suxxxxx. Everyone knows about the red flags, but there's enough there in his performance and obvious raw talent that I have a hard time believing that there are numbers so damning that someone can authoritatively state that he's not a good player.
Old-Timey Member
Posted
yeah I can't see any world where the guy sucks. There is an argument he won't be a great player, but that's about it.
Posted
The most interesting thing about Puig is that some people (JFaS) are comfortable saying that he outright suxxxxx. Everyone knows about the red flags, but there's enough there in his performance and obvious raw talent that I have a hard time believing that there are numbers so damning that someone can authoritatively state that he's not a good player.

 

Maybe he got in a bar fight with Puig before and is just holding a grudge.

Posted
You state facts, but even with the lovely wOBAs he was a guy that couldn't find it in himself to yank 20 over the fence, and he's probably done stealing double digit bases. There's some inherent risk in the basic statistical profile in a fantasy sense. No idea what type of player he will be production wise. All we really know is that he has a special hitting ability and obviously some raw juice - which is all that can be said about a lot of top hitting prospects, like his teammate C.Seags.

 

I'm not so worried about his HR power in a league like this where he contributes extensively in OBP/SLG/H. I do think he'll top 20 HR several times in his career, personally.

Posted
yeah I can't see any world where the guy sucks. There is an argument he won't be a great player, but that's about it.

 

If someone wants to say he's not the star he appears to be thus far, I can kinda buy that, but he objectively does not suck.

Posted
The most interesting thing about Puig is that some people (JFaS) are comfortable saying that he outright suxxxxx. Everyone knows about the red flags, but there's enough there in his performance and obvious raw talent that I have a hard time believing that there are numbers so damning that someone can authoritatively state that he's not a good player.

 

JFaS rarely ever seems to think in anything but black and white, I've noticed. While I value his knowledge, he's too stubborn about things and comes to conclusions too quickly for my liking.

Posted

What's the market for RP like?

 

I'd love to combine a "lottery ticket" SP or "s***" "bag" like Kelly/Folty/Gallardo with milb 10 or 19 for someone good.

Posted
What's the market for RP like?

 

I'd love to combine a "lottery ticket" SP or "s***" "bag" like Kelly/Folty/Gallardo with milb 10 or 19 for someone good.

 

Papsmear got moved for pick #25 or something like that. Koji got moved for a pick in the 30s, I think. You could get a good closer for MiLB 10 if someone was selling.

Community Moderator
Posted
The most interesting thing about Puig is that some people (JFaS) are comfortable saying that he outright suxxxxx. Everyone knows about the red flags, but there's enough there in his performance and obvious raw talent that I have a hard time believing that there are numbers so damning that someone can authoritatively state that he's not a good player.

 

The suxxxx is relative to expectations, obviously.

Old-Timey Member
Posted

Andrew Miller is available for a good return. Preferably a hitter or upgrade on one of my hitters.

 

or Jason Grilli if you feel like gambling.

Community Moderator
Posted
And he isn't even getting shot down, lmao.

 

reddit suxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

 

This seems like a job for the BJMB crew

Posted
Well I for one am sold. And since Pillar would make a good leadoff hitter too maybe he should bat 2nd. It's like 2 leadoff hitters. We'd be unstoppable!
Posted
Well I for one am sold. And since Pillar would make a good leadoff hitter too maybe he should bat 2nd. It's like 2 leadoff hitters. We'd be unstoppable!

 

Ugghhh... Wilner just brought this up again(Pilar leading off). I really hope he isn't getting that from Gibbons.

Posted
Ugghhh... Wilner just brought this up again(Pilar leading off). I really hope he isn't getting that from Gibbons.

 

Guy I work with keeps saying he thinks Pillar would be a good lead off.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Blue Jays community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...