Mets. First game I ever attended was at Shea Stadium when I was 10, July 1989. Glen Close (a friend of my moms) got us tickets. They were playing the Reds. Pete Rose was manager and a day or two before it had been revealed that he bet on baseball. This was one of his last games in baseball. Darrell Strawberry was slumping at the plate so the fans were booing him until he saved a HR and threw out a runner at second in one motion. The boos were replaced by screams of "we love you Darrell!". Eric Davis tore his MCL? or ACL? and was never the same again. A personal highlight was when unbeknownst to my brothers and I, Glen had prearranged to put our names on the score board it looked like this: THE METS WELCOME and Robin Williams and Billy Crystal
I can just picture them saying "who the f*** are those guys?" Incidentally, our family recorded the game on VHS for us and sure enough, Williams and Crystal commentated a couple of innings with Crystal being the color guy and Williams pretending to be from Russia and scoffing at American rules.
The real highlights came in the final innings. The night before, Juan Samuel (Mets), Tim Teufel (Mets), Norm Charlton (Reds) and Rob Dibble (Reds... who some of you may remember as the ass in "Best damn show in sports period") got into a fight. It started on the field when Dibble deliberately plunked Teufel who then charged the mound, (benches clearing) and continued into the locker room with Samuel beating the s*** out of Dibble. Samuel was benched for the game I attended and everyone expected Dibble to be suspended as well. In the late innings, Dibble came in relief with the Reds ahead. The fans started chanting DIBBLE! DIBBLE! like only a NY crowd can (I swear it was shaking the stadium). He walked the first batter on 4 pitches. The Mets pinch hit with Samuel who promptly crushed a ball over the right field fence. Mets win.
So yeah, its the Mets for me.
Here is a NY Times perspective on the game if anyone is interested:
http://www.nytimes.com/1989/07/10/sports/samuel-s-homer-soothing-to-mets.html