I've seen this a lot on here lately that Rogers has been outstanding since the payroll is top 10 etc... Now I agree with almost every point you made but would you say the payroll is reasonable if the Jays had top 5 revenue and profit in baseball?
If the Yankees and Red Sox had a payroll in the $160 range their fans wouldn't be happy because it is "top 10 in baseball", they know like everyone else it should be top 5 because of the amount of revenue brought in by the club.
So my question is this, "As a Blue Jays fan if you knew that Rogers was making say $30-50 million per season on the Blue Jays would you think payroll was reasonable"?