I missed the Carter home run as I was coming home from a wedding, so I'll go with the Jays winning the 1992 World Series. I went down to the Dome with my parents, as the game was televised on the Jumbotron. The place was packed, but we got seats on the lower level, near right field. When Carter made the final out, it was pandemonium. Toilet paper was flying from the stands, fans started running on the field. Because the game ended so late, we had to leave pretty quickly to make the train, but I asked my mother if I could go onto the field. Fans were gingerly walking down the steps to climb over the barrier. I was on the field, and tried to soak it in, but felt a little uncomfortable going out to the diamond where everyone was partying, so I went back to my parents, and we went home. Yonge Street was packed. I feel sorry for those young Toronto sports fans who haven't experienced what the city was like when teams were good. To get caught up in the excitement.
http://cdn.thegridto.com/wp-content/uploads/635.jpg
Second moment would be Alomar hitting the home run to tie game 4 in the 1992 ALCS. This was back when the playoffs coincided with Thanksgiving, so we all rushed from the dinner table to catch the rally.
Third would be the Jays winning the 1992 Pennant. The game was on in the afternoon. I ran home from school to find the Jays were in the lead. This was around the time of "Winfield Wants Noise", and you've never heard the dome so loud. The Jays giddy as Henke was on the mound, and finally as the ball was caught. For the longest time the team was known by fans as the "Blow Jays", so it was such a great feeling to seem them get over the hump.
It would be so great to go back to those days with the team we have now.