Great comparison. An older, more advanced prospect who had hit at every level he's played in versus two 20 year old's in A-ball who haven't thrown more than 80 innings in a season.
Please. The only "rookies" who warranted a spot on the big league club out of spring training were Travis and possibly Norris, and that's only because Stroman was hurt. Otherwise, every single one of Norris, Pompey, Sanchez, Osuna, and Castro should have been in the minors to begin the year. And yes, I realize Pompey hasn't been bad, but he still could have used some development time. Pillar in CF would have been fine.