I'm trying to separate my desire for retribution from how I feel about this. I've been so bitter about the Dickey trade for years that a big part of me wants to see AA punished for it even to this day. At the same time, I believe AA has been slowly getting better and does indeed learn from his mistakes. The Price trade looks terrible now as well (and really that was going to happen with anything less than a WS), but I don't think it was nearly as bad. AA at least correctly assessed that the team was better than their record and gave up a top prospect but one that was showing warts at least. The Donaldson trade was stellar. Martin signing was very good. The Revere trade was defensible, the Tulowitzki trade was defensible (although I have a slight Reyes 2.0 vibe from him). There's a lot of recent good here.
So in the end, a part of me is saying "f*** you" to AA, but if I'm objective and take emotion out of it: this is bad. When you invest in a person who has lot of upside and good attributes, but is lacking in experience, you have to ride it out for a while. Seems like we're letting him go just as he's starting to come into his own.
Granted, I don't know the full details. Maybe the Jays put something very reasonable in front of him and he rejected it because he completely overrates himself, who knows.